Popular Mechanics this week published a piece about how aliens could be wrapping up stars and black holes in devices that can suck out their energy. According to the author, we may want to do something similar in order to have enough energy to power some kind of virtual reality to which people could upload their minds.
This is your daily reminder that Space Science is literally just fan fiction, no different than writing about imaginary technology from Star Trek or Star Wars lore.
You probably think of a Dyson sphere as a structure that captures the sun’s energy, but what would happen if you built one around a black hole instead?
A global coalition of scientists are in pursuit of the answer, analyzing six different types of energy that we could hypothetically harness from a black hole. What they find could help us reveal what a next-generation galactic civilization might look like, and even help us locate those extraterrestrials in the process.
What is a Dyson Sphere?
For the uninitiated, prolific scholar Freeman Dyson first described his namesake Dyson sphere concept in a landmark 1960 paper. At the heart of his theory is a simple—but tantalizing—question: if a civilization grew large enough, and traveled far enough afield into outer space, how would it have enough energy to power itself?
Dyson’s answer is the Dyson sphere, or “a hollow ball built around the sun [that] would solve the space and energy problems,” according to his paper. Therefore, it’s a theoretical device that sits around an entire star and harvests its energy. Its goal is to help power a civilization whose energy demands have simply eclipsed their planet’s natural potential. It’s part of Dyson’s broader suggestion that the Search for Extra Terrestrial Intelligence (SETI) should set their sights on the kind of energy signature that such an item could discharge.
Yeah, why don’t we just like, build a device that can harvest all of this energy and solve all of our problems? Then we can just like, build like some sort of device that just kinda recirculates the energy and like, makes it recyclable and green, so we just kind of like, you know, have unlimited energy? I’m writing a paper about this.
Oh, wait. I have a better idea. Let’s ask the ayy lmaos how they’re doing it!
How Much Energy Would an Alien Civilization Really Need?
Dyson spheres all tie back to a system called the Kardashev scale, which is based on how much energy a civilization consumes. Earth, for instance, is a type 1 civilization under this rating system, because we only use the amount of energy available on our own planet. In the new paper, published earlier this summer in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, the researchers ponder what it would take to power a type 2 or type 3 civilization, whose energy needs consume their entire solar system:
“The purpose of this study is to discuss the possibility of black holes being a candidate for an energy source to build a Dyson Sphere of a civilisation between a Type II and a Type III…After a Type II civilisation absorbs all the energy from the parent star, a Type II civilisation would seek another star to maintain itself. We would like to answer the question if black holes can be regarded as proper energy sources, or if they are inefficient to provide ample energy for civilisations to thrive.”
How could Earth become a type 2 civilization? In the most literal way, we’d have to harvest energy from not only the sun, but from Jupiter (which is almost a star, itself) and everything else available to us in our solar system.
The natural follow-up question is why we’d need that much energy in the first place. This, it turns out, is pretty easy to answer as we speed into the 2020s and beyond. Think about the energy required to carry more and more people into space as the world’s billionaires venture outside of our planet, plus the energy demands for NASA’s own ambitions to install people on the moon. Alternately, you can think about an entire world powered by electric batteries instead of fossil fuels.
In the longer term, consider the concept of uploading people’s consciousnesses to some kind of data storage center, as proposed in an episode of the dystopian anthology series Black Mirror. In “San Junipero,” two young women meet and fall in love from inside a server farm, while their bodies exist in vegetative states in the real world.
“You will live in a vegetative state and be happy,” Weird Dark Sorcerer says.
Let’s say an individual’s memories and mind fit into 2.5 terabytes of storage, which is an extremely low estimate—that means there’s a server farm somewhere with 20 billion terabytes, which is 20 million petabytes, or about 20 exabytes. That’s 20 times the data that Amazon Web Services holds, and it’s effectively the storage backbone of the entire internet at the moment.
So, it’s easy to see how much energy this electronic infrastructure alone would take up, let alone the heat sink and cooling to make sure all of the electronics can run safely and sustainably. This is the point at which an Earth far into the future might need to harness the full power of the sun, and the point at which we’d become a Kardashev type 2 civilization.
“We need more energy so we can put all of these people into The Matrix even though literally nobody asked for it and literally nobody will benefit from it.”
It sounds like a joke, but they’re dead serious about it.
Using Dyson Spheres to Find Extraterrestrials
The researchers conclude by showing what SETI should look for if a type 2 civilization is hypothetically using Dyson sphere technology to collect energy from in and around a black hole. This, they say, will likely be in the form of waste heat that we can observe with infrared spectrum technology. All black hole measurements may look roughly alike, but there will be “abnormal peaks” on those that are likely housing Dyson sphere technologies, the scientists say.
Earth is far from using a Dyson sphere to harvest our sun, Jupiter, or even a black hole. But by analyzing what such an object would look like and leave behind as excess heat, scientists are better able to search the cosmos for that signature—and find any new neighbors who are running Dyson spheres on their nearest black hole.
It really seems like the main purpose of all of this talk about space and imaginary tech is to manipulate people into believing aliens are real, smarter than us, and just around the corner.